Cookout Fresh Peanut Butter

It costs $2.79. Prices come from live ordering menus and move a few cents between cities, so treat that as the going rate and confirm at your restaurant.

Cookout does not publish a topping list for this one, so the build varies slightly by restaurant. Ask at the window if you want it plain or with extras, since nothing is added by default beyond the standard build.

Trays bundle a main with two sides and a large drink from $2.99. Check the trays menu for which mains are available as a tray at your restaurant.

At 847 calories it is one of the bigger single items on the menu, though the heaviest is BBQ Plate at 976 calories. Two sides on top of it will push a meal well past 1,200 calories.

At 847 calories it sits above the milkshake average of 693. All 36 flavors are priced from $2.79 and listed with calories on the milkshake menu.